Oddworld Forums > Zulag Two > Off-Topic Discussion


 
Thread Tools
 
  #1  
03-02-2009, 07:12 AM
Wings of Fire's Avatar
Wings of Fire
Beautiful Bastard
 
: Dec 2007
: Stafford
: 9,537
Blog Entries: 143
Rep Power: 33
Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)
Anarchy

Would a state of anarchy be good or bad for the populace of any given first world country and why?

The main two theories to contrast here are that of Thomas Hobbes who in his book Leviathan stated that the 'State of Nature' would be a land of scarcity, no industry would thrive because why on earth would you plant a tree if you're not fully entitled to the apple and people would generally be distrustful of eachother, leading to a perpetual state of war. Without central authority there would be no insurance that you are not a constant target of other peoples' opression and each and every person would know this.

Contrast Rousseau who believed that pre-society earth was a fantastic forest of plenty, where humans led primarily solitary lives without fear of leaderships or persecution, there would always be enough apples provided by nature herself as every man would only take what he needed. Greed is a contrivance of the state and fear of other people taking what we want is a purely social phenonoma manufactured by a feudal/capitalist evolution of society.

Basically think The Coral island vs Lord of the Flies.
__________________
:
“I always believe the movies I've made are smarter than the way they are perceived by sort of mass culture and by the critics,” Snyder said, a statement he immediately followed by saying, “Also, ‘It looks like a video game.’

Reply With Quote
  #2  
03-02-2009, 07:32 AM
OANST's Avatar
OANST
Necrum Burial Grounds Moderator
Our worst member ever
 
: Jun 2003
: Them dark fucking woods
: 12,320
Blog Entries: 134
Rep Power: 41
OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)

We should ask Abe Is Now. He would know.
__________________


My bowels hurt.

Reply With Quote
  #3  
03-02-2009, 07:36 AM
Hobo's Avatar
Hobo
Honorary Smod
Chronically Awesome
 
: Feb 2003
: London
: 6,741
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 29
Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)

Seconded OANST's idea.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
03-02-2009, 09:05 AM
oko's Avatar
oko
Boombat
 
: Nov 2002
: your butt
: 244
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 23
oko  (33)

:
Without central authority there would be no insurance that you are not a constant target of other peoples' opression and each and every person would know this.
Thankfully, we have a central authority that does insure that we are a constant target for oppression.

I believe communitarian anarchy could work in an industrialized society, but primitive societies are more suited for that kind of government. The bushmen along with other hunter-gatherer societies live in anarchy and it works quite well for them.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
03-02-2009, 09:08 AM
OANST's Avatar
OANST
Necrum Burial Grounds Moderator
Our worst member ever
 
: Jun 2003
: Them dark fucking woods
: 12,320
Blog Entries: 134
Rep Power: 41
OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)OANST  (16390)

On a more serious note, I recommend that you read a book called 'The Dispossessed (an ambiguous utopia)'. It does a good job of trying to answer these questions without really picking a side.


Edit: This book contains the origin of the ansible, a machine that is used by many SF writers.
__________________


My bowels hurt.


Last edited by OANST; 03-02-2009 at 09:49 AM..
Reply With Quote
  #6  
03-02-2009, 03:14 PM
Bullet Magnet's Avatar
Bullet Magnet
Bayesian Empirimancer
 
: Apr 2006
: Greatish Britain
: 7,724
Blog Entries: 130
Rep Power: 30
Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)

Rousseau clearly had no understanding of early man or prehistoric times. A desperate age of fear and death, where humans, who were most certainly not solitary, struggled to survive, competed with one another and other groups for resources (food, land, shelter, mates etc), and died before thirty years of age, often of the loss of their own teeth.
__________________
| (• ◡•)|  (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

Reply With Quote
  #7  
03-02-2009, 03:55 PM
Mac Sirloin's Avatar
Mac Sirloin
Less worse
 
: Aug 2006
: Exquisite Squalor
: 5,657
Blog Entries: 301
Rep Power: 27
Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)

Anarchy sucks because it's meaning is lost on just about everyone who thinks it would be a good idea.

Truth.
__________________
I see you jockin' me.

Reply With Quote
  #8  
03-02-2009, 03:58 PM
Wings of Fire's Avatar
Wings of Fire
Beautiful Bastard
 
: Dec 2007
: Stafford
: 9,537
Blog Entries: 143
Rep Power: 33
Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)

:
Anarchy sucks because it's meaning is lost on just about everyone who thinks it would be a good idea.

Truth.
Even Political Philosophers?
__________________
:
“I always believe the movies I've made are smarter than the way they are perceived by sort of mass culture and by the critics,” Snyder said, a statement he immediately followed by saying, “Also, ‘It looks like a video game.’

Reply With Quote
  #9  
03-02-2009, 04:14 PM
Mac Sirloin's Avatar
Mac Sirloin
Less worse
 
: Aug 2006
: Exquisite Squalor
: 5,657
Blog Entries: 301
Rep Power: 27
Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)

:
Even Political Philosophers?
(Just about everyone)

Meaning your typical dipshit teenager.

People who know what the fuck they're talking about are excluded.

That's why I'm still in this discussion.
__________________
I see you jockin' me.

Reply With Quote
  #10  
03-02-2009, 05:37 PM
used:)'s Avatar
used:)
Symphonium
 
: Jun 2005
: Tranquil Vestiges, PA
: 5,161
Blog Entries: 42
Rep Power: 26
used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)

It's a stupid form of society and lies at the very heart of conservativism.

I might enjoy it, though.
Reply With Quote
  #11  
03-02-2009, 06:52 PM
Nemo
Clakker Store Clerk
 
: Oct 2006
: ǐͣ͋͗̄
: 793
Blog Entries: 281
Rep Power: 19
Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)

I dislike people who just look at anarchy and think "omg wtf u sux0rs."

I'm not a left-wing liberal dick who thinks that there shouldn't be a government because of all the computer chips that they've installed into my mind, and I'm not a right-wing gun-totin' douche who thinks that hippies who oppose America can go to hell either.

In a setting in which Anarchy would work, I support it. In a setting in which it would ruin everything, I don't. No one system works in every situation.
Reply With Quote
  #12  
03-02-2009, 07:01 PM
used:)'s Avatar
used:)
Symphonium
 
: Jun 2005
: Tranquil Vestiges, PA
: 5,161
Blog Entries: 42
Rep Power: 26
used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)

:
In a setting in which Anarchy would work, I support it. In a setting in which it would ruin everything, I don't. No one system works in every situation.
Um, duh...
Reply With Quote
  #13  
03-02-2009, 07:39 PM
Nemo
Clakker Store Clerk
 
: Oct 2006
: ǐͣ͋͗̄
: 793
Blog Entries: 281
Rep Power: 19
Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)Nemo  (404)

I know it's obvious.
Reply With Quote
  #14  
03-02-2009, 08:22 PM
Nate's Avatar
Nate
Oddworld Administrator
Rainbow of Flavour
 
: Apr 2002
: Seattle (woo!)
: 16,311
Blog Entries: 176
Rep Power: 42
Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)Nate  (13497)

I think the better thing for you to say would be to describe the setting in which it works and how it would work...
__________________
:
Spending as long as I do here, it's easy to forget that Oddworld has actual fans.

Reply With Quote
  #15  
03-03-2009, 04:02 AM
used:)'s Avatar
used:)
Symphonium
 
: Jun 2005
: Tranquil Vestiges, PA
: 5,161
Blog Entries: 42
Rep Power: 26
used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)

A world without scarcity.
Reply With Quote
  #16  
03-03-2009, 04:15 AM
AlexFili's Avatar
AlexFili
Wolvark Shooter
 
: Feb 2009
: NorthWest of England
: 3,127
Blog Entries: 78
Rep Power: 19
AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)AlexFili  (1280)

Anarchy generally doesnt work.
__________________

[B]
I stream games and art now!
http://twitch.tv/ZephyrFloofyDerg
floofyderg.live

Reply With Quote
  #17  
03-03-2009, 04:43 AM
Bullet Magnet's Avatar
Bullet Magnet
Bayesian Empirimancer
 
: Apr 2006
: Greatish Britain
: 7,724
Blog Entries: 130
Rep Power: 30
Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)

:
A world without scarcity.
A world without treachery, hate or ambition.
__________________
| (• ◡•)|  (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

Reply With Quote
  #18  
03-03-2009, 05:23 AM
oko's Avatar
oko
Boombat
 
: Nov 2002
: your butt
: 244
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 23
oko  (33)

:
Rousseau clearly had no understanding of early man or prehistoric times. A desperate age of fear and death, where humans, who were most certainly not solitary, struggled to survive, competed with one another and other groups for resources (food, land, shelter, mates etc), and died before thirty years of age, often of the loss of their own teeth.
I'll agree with the first sentence, in that he seems to be guessing instead of actually having done some research. But I'll have to challenge some of what you said. I'll base this on the upper paleolithic era. humans lived in tribes or bands of 25-100 individuals before the onset of agriculture. Average lifespan then was 33, so most died after the age of thirty, and they had potential to live till 60+ even thought it was rare. Food was usually plentiful, northern and eastern Europe had heavy reindeer and horse populations, America had buffalo, and I don't think I even need to mention Africa. Most of these animals traveled in herds, and therefor could be hunted in great numbers. They were nomads and would move when food became scarce in a region. Depending on populations where the tribe lived, there would ussualy be more than enough land for everyone. They often lived in tents of animal skin. As to loosing their teeth, most of the evidence I've seen points towards populations on a natural or "caveman" diet having excellent dental health. They may have lost teeth due to injury or malnutrition during periods with food shortage, but I don't think teeth loss was a leading cause of death.

I think life might have been really good during this time. When not hunting, most time would be spent around a campfire partying, socializing and playing sports

sources:
http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/...#ref=ref424412
http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn7035
http://journeytoforever.org/farm_lib.../pricetoc.html

EDIT: A world without jealousy!

Last edited by oko; 03-03-2009 at 07:53 AM..
Reply With Quote
  #19  
03-03-2009, 05:54 AM
Wings of Fire's Avatar
Wings of Fire
Beautiful Bastard
 
: Dec 2007
: Stafford
: 9,537
Blog Entries: 143
Rep Power: 33
Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)

:
A world without treachery, hate or ambition.
Can you prove that those desires are not founded by the concept of Authority?
__________________
:
“I always believe the movies I've made are smarter than the way they are perceived by sort of mass culture and by the critics,” Snyder said, a statement he immediately followed by saying, “Also, ‘It looks like a video game.’

Reply With Quote
  #20  
03-03-2009, 02:05 PM
used:)'s Avatar
used:)
Symphonium
 
: Jun 2005
: Tranquil Vestiges, PA
: 5,161
Blog Entries: 42
Rep Power: 26
used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)used:)  (3040)

I think he means that they're founded on the concept of scarcity.
Reply With Quote
  #21  
03-03-2009, 11:07 PM
Strike Witch's Avatar
Strike Witch
Laserguns!
 
: Jan 2003
: 気持ちপ
: 4,311
Blog Entries: 246
Rep Power: 28
Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)

We should bring back Gladiatorial combat to replace War.
__________________
Ah, we are high school boys,
the miserable high school boys.
If we were girls, we could get popular by doing anything:
rock band, jazz band,
karate, kendo, mahjong, cyborg, synchronized swimming...
On the other hand, high school boys are
useless outside battle and sports anime.
But they're recklessly trying to make a slice-of-life anime about us.
Ah, we are high school boys,
the miserable high school boys.

Reply With Quote
  #22  
03-04-2009, 06:59 AM
Hobo's Avatar
Hobo
Honorary Smod
Chronically Awesome
 
: Feb 2003
: London
: 6,741
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 29
Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)

And sex.
Reply With Quote


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 








 
 
- Oddworld Forums - -