Oddworld Forums > Zulag Two > Off-Topic Discussion


 
Thread Tools
 
  #1  
01-22-2008, 07:24 PM
mudling's Avatar
mudling
Outlaw Sniper
 
: Jan 2005
: Sydney
: 1,631
Rep Power: 22
mudling  (123)mudling  (123)
Race

Race is an incorrect word, human is a race, hence the term "human race", so a "white" and "black" man are the same race.
__________________

Reply With Quote
  #2  
01-23-2008, 01:02 AM
Bullet Magnet's Avatar
Bullet Magnet
Bayesian Empirimancer
 
: Apr 2006
: Greatish Britain
: 7,724
Blog Entries: 130
Rep Power: 30
Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)

:
think of it as humans and their supposed "races" (Race is an incorrect word, human is a race, hence the term "human race", so a "white" and "black" man are the same race).
No, race is the right word. It's used the same way as "varieties" are in, say, plants. We're certainly no less different from each other than the subspecies of tigers. It is an interesting juxtaposition, where science has stepped back for our own good.
__________________
| (• ◡•)|  (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

Reply With Quote
  #3  
01-23-2008, 09:03 PM
mudling's Avatar
mudling
Outlaw Sniper
 
: Jan 2005
: Sydney
: 1,631
Rep Power: 22
mudling  (123)mudling  (123)

Yes it is the right word, but politcally incorrect, this is according to my history teacher so don't get me wrong, but Nazi scientists created these terms in order to seperate the "race" of causian or whatever it's called, from the others, making it superior.
It's all nonence becuase race means different genetic material, or something along the lines, which means two races cannot reproduce successfully (A donkey and a horse can mate, but not sucsessfully, as in, their child will not be able to reproduce ).
But this word has been put into general use, so using it is considered right, even though it is wrong
Just trying to be politcally correct and racial aware (That is, avoiding saying something that may offended someone of a different "race")
__________________

Reply With Quote
  #4  
01-23-2008, 09:40 PM
Bullet Magnet's Avatar
Bullet Magnet
Bayesian Empirimancer
 
: Apr 2006
: Greatish Britain
: 7,724
Blog Entries: 130
Rep Power: 30
Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)

Nazi scientists? Those are way older than nazism. They simply seized upon it.

But no, when used properly the term "race" and its synonyms operate below the division of species, so races, varieties, subspecies, whatever you want to call them, of a species will be able to reproduce successfully. In fact, that is a problem when trying to preserve subspecies of, say, tigers.

As I say, I can't think of any non-arbitrary reason that we do not apply this to ourselves other than the extremely necessary evasion of eugenics.
__________________
| (• ◡•)|  (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)


Last edited by Bullet Magnet; 01-30-2008 at 07:36 AM..
Reply With Quote
  #5  
01-24-2008, 06:24 PM
Sanssouci's Avatar
Sanssouci
Fuzzle
 
: Jan 2008
: where
: 139
Rep Power: 18
Sanssouci  (131)Sanssouci  (131)

:
No, race is the right word. It's used the same way as "varieties" are in, say, plants. We're certainly no less different from each other than the subspecies of tigers.
You are shockingly incorrect.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
01-24-2008, 08:44 PM
Bullet Magnet's Avatar
Bullet Magnet
Bayesian Empirimancer
 
: Apr 2006
: Greatish Britain
: 7,724
Blog Entries: 130
Rep Power: 30
Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)

It's fine to disagree with me but it would help if you would elaborate more. Anyone can make an assertion.
__________________
| (• ◡•)|  (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

Reply With Quote
  #7  
01-25-2008, 01:54 AM
Wil's Avatar
Wil
Oddworld Administrator
Oddworld Inhabitant
 
: Apr 2001
: UK
: 13,534
Blog Entries: 39
Rep Power: 40
Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)Wil  (9443)

What’s more shocking is that Sanssouci registered just to say that. In the interests of topic preservation, I’m moving certain posts to OT.
__________________

Reply With Quote
  #8  
01-25-2008, 03:31 AM
Strike Witch's Avatar
Strike Witch
Laserguns!
 
: Jan 2003
: 気持ちপ
: 4,311
Blog Entries: 246
Rep Power: 28
Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)Strike Witch  (4900)

Where he'll never find it again and think it was deleted? Nice one, Max :P
__________________
Ah, we are high school boys,
the miserable high school boys.
If we were girls, we could get popular by doing anything:
rock band, jazz band,
karate, kendo, mahjong, cyborg, synchronized swimming...
On the other hand, high school boys are
useless outside battle and sports anime.
But they're recklessly trying to make a slice-of-life anime about us.
Ah, we are high school boys,
the miserable high school boys.

Reply With Quote
  #9  
01-25-2008, 03:49 AM
Mac Sirloin's Avatar
Mac Sirloin
Less worse
 
: Aug 2006
: Exquisite Squalor
: 5,657
Blog Entries: 301
Rep Power: 27
Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)

Never, ever disagree with Bullet Magnet.

He will intellectually checkmate you, all in good humour, as well.
__________________
I see you jockin' me.

Reply With Quote
  #10  
01-25-2008, 05:23 AM
abe is now!'s Avatar
abe is now!
Mafia, Pizza & Mandolino
 
: Jan 2007
: Italy
: 2,825
Blog Entries: 25
Rep Power: 21
abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)

I have always thought humans belong to animal kingdom, so I have always thought they are a race.
__________________
ain!

Reply With Quote
  #11  
01-25-2008, 11:54 AM
Salamander's Avatar
Salamander
Rabid Fuzzle
 
: May 2005
: Anigav
: 549
Blog Entries: 6
Rep Power: 21
Salamander  (79)

:
Yes it is the right word, but politcally incorrect, this is according to my history teacher so don't get me wrong, but Nazi scientists created these terms in order to seperate the "race" of causian or whatever it's called, from the others, making it superior.
It's all nonence becuase race means different genetic material, or something along the lines, which means two races cannot reproduce successfully (A donkey and a horse can mate, but not sucsessfully, as in, their child will not be able to reproduce ).
But this word has been put into general use, so using it is considered right, even though it is wrong
Just trying to be politcally correct and racial aware (That is, avoiding saying something that may offended someone of a different "race")
Why do you use smilies when they're not relevant or appropriate?

In other news; BM is correct.
__________________
Last edited by Salamander : Today at 05:18 PM.

Reply With Quote
  #12  
01-26-2008, 07:36 AM
Rex Tirano's Avatar
Rex Tirano
Cute as a rabbit
 
: Aug 2001
: Nagasaki
: 2,259
Rep Power: 25
Rex Tirano  (682)Rex Tirano  (682)Rex Tirano  (682)Rex Tirano  (682)Rex Tirano  (682)Rex Tirano  (682)

Pfft, it's not like we actually need any more Political Correctness. FFS, the world's gone crazy with it already.

If we didn't use the word 'race', what word would you use?

- Rexy
__________________
ブルータスよ、我々がつまらない人間でいる責任は、
運にあるのではなく、自分達自身にあるのだ.

Reply With Quote
  #13  
01-26-2008, 09:15 AM
abe is now!'s Avatar
abe is now!
Mafia, Pizza & Mandolino
 
: Jan 2007
: Italy
: 2,825
Blog Entries: 25
Rep Power: 21
abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)

:
If we didn't use the word 'race', what word would you use?
I'd use nationality or caste. I think they are more respectful than "race".
__________________
ain!

Reply With Quote
  #14  
01-26-2008, 09:22 AM
AlienMagi
Clakker Relic Miner
 
: Aug 2007
: In the dark
: 830
Blog Entries: 5
Rep Power: 18
AlienMagi  (118)AlienMagi  (118)

Actually race has two meanings...
1. Like racing with cars, bikes etc.
2. Like human race, alien race...

And if word race is bad for you guys... well we could say species right? xD
Reply With Quote
  #15  
01-26-2008, 09:37 AM
Wings of Fire's Avatar
Wings of Fire
Beautiful Bastard
 
: Dec 2007
: Stafford
: 9,537
Blog Entries: 143
Rep Power: 33
Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)

:
I'd use nationality or caste. I think they are more respectful than "race".
Nationality is something different altogether. If someone called me a 'Fucking limey' They're hardly being racist.
:
Actually race has two meanings...
1. Like racing with cars, bikes etc.
2. Like human race, alien race...

And if word race is bad for you guys... well we could say species right? xD
Species is also something completely different.

No matter what we look like or what pigmentation our skin is we are still Homo-Sapien.
__________________
:
“I always believe the movies I've made are smarter than the way they are perceived by sort of mass culture and by the critics,” Snyder said, a statement he immediately followed by saying, “Also, ‘It looks like a video game.’

Reply With Quote
  #16  
01-26-2008, 09:40 AM
abe is now!'s Avatar
abe is now!
Mafia, Pizza & Mandolino
 
: Jan 2007
: Italy
: 2,825
Blog Entries: 25
Rep Power: 21
abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)

:
Nationality is something different altogether. If someone called me a 'Fucking limey' They're hardly being racist.
But if I am Italian and you are English (for example) it's not racism. It depends by how everyone consider thw word "nationality".
__________________
ain!

Reply With Quote
  #17  
01-26-2008, 09:41 AM
Hobo's Avatar
Hobo
Honorary Smod
Chronically Awesome
 
: Feb 2003
: London
: 6,741
Blog Entries: 1
Rep Power: 29
Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)Hobo  (3434)

Rexy wins the thread. What does it bloody matter?
Reply With Quote
  #18  
01-26-2008, 10:42 AM
mitsur's Avatar
mitsur
Corporate Espionage
 
: May 2001
: ಠ_ಠ
: 2,060
Blog Entries: 45
Rep Power: 26
mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)

:
Pfft, it's not like we actually need any more Political Correctness. FFS, the world's gone crazy with it already.

If we didn't use the word 'race', what word would you use?

- Rexy
Agreed. Politically-Correct people are a waste of my time, and they should stop worrying about what words are neutral.
__________________

Wrex.

Reply With Quote
  #19  
01-26-2008, 11:19 AM
AlienMagi
Clakker Relic Miner
 
: Aug 2007
: In the dark
: 830
Blog Entries: 5
Rep Power: 18
AlienMagi  (118)AlienMagi  (118)

:
Species is also something completely different.
AlienMagi:Yes I know I was kidding.

No matter what we look like or what pigmentation our skin is we are still Homo-Sapien.
Agreed. If you ask me it doesn't even matter how we look like... we re all people.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
01-26-2008, 11:24 AM
mudling's Avatar
mudling
Outlaw Sniper
 
: Jan 2005
: Sydney
: 1,631
Rep Power: 22
mudling  (123)mudling  (123)

WTF, I never made this a topic, seriously guys, I didn't mean this to be a full blown argument/ disscussion so relax.
*Edit* Realised it was probably Max who did this, and I realise why and it was all in good intentions, sorry I was just confused*
And it's not about politcal correctness, you shouldn't even use the word race unless you're reffering to humans, we shouldn't need to use the word racist becuase people shouldn't descriminate other "races" (and we wouldn't use that word, if we didn't have people trying to discriminate against each other).
Ok, think humanity, or the human race as a jumper, and these "races" are all threads, some person wants to seperate themselves from the others, so they are not attached to the other, genetically speaking, and so they are sperate from them, so the term race is used.
Oh, and Salamnder, I use smilies to make light of the situation, and to ease tention when going through uneasy toppics of argument, and in general, to help make everyone cheerier, so with that in mind, they are relevant.
__________________


Last edited by mudling; 01-26-2008 at 11:30 AM..
Reply With Quote
  #21  
01-26-2008, 03:13 PM
mitsur's Avatar
mitsur
Corporate Espionage
 
: May 2001
: ಠ_ಠ
: 2,060
Blog Entries: 45
Rep Power: 26
mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)mitsur  (452)

:
WTF, I never made this a topic, seriously guys, I didn't mean this to be a full blown argument/ disscussion so relax.

It's not up to you if we decide something is worth arguing over, people here usually love to go off on tangents anyway.

But as I said, I am full of contempt for the people who are obsessed with being politically correct, or are offended by a word or phrase that 'demeans their race'. Like how midgets think it's a deragatory term, how they prefer 'little-people'. Midget is not a word that's supposed to make fun of them, in my mind.

While I agree their are some terms for other people that should'nt be used in any way since they are hurtful (the most prominent one is, of course, nigger), the vast majority of terms used these days to describe different types of people are not in any way hurtful or demeaning. But some people are apparently so afraid of getting sued or offending someone that they want to make 100% sure people cannot take it the wrong way. Even if the people who get offended by it should be slapped anyway for being so mentally or emotionally sensitive about their heritage.
__________________

Wrex.

Reply With Quote
  #22  
01-26-2008, 03:40 PM
Bullet Magnet's Avatar
Bullet Magnet
Bayesian Empirimancer
 
: Apr 2006
: Greatish Britain
: 7,724
Blog Entries: 130
Rep Power: 30
Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)Bullet Magnet  (8784)

I was just pointing out that "race" simply determines different varieties within a species, often emerged through geographical isolation, and can be seen in many species besides humans, though we do not tend to call those "races" so much as "varieties" and even "subspecies". The latter of which, if applied to people, would be an interpretational minefield, assuming of course that the human races had diverged enough to be called such. Such diversion is quickly deteriorating with modern travel, now that few populaions are truly geogaphically isolated.

I just think it is interesting the way we attempt to preserve the subspecies or other organisms, but only the worst people in the world are interested in doing the same to people. And I am very much opposed to that sort of attitude, I just think it is an interesting insight into he values we place on humanity. Clearly concerns about discrimination feature heavily, and free will (the freedom to choose a partner of a different race to reproduce with, for example). Evolution is what made the races appear, the early onset of speciation, but that is being reversed by our ability to globally integrate.

Again, what I find interesting is the way we as conservationists are horrified to see that occur in the animal and plant kingdoms, as part of the loss of diversity that the current mass extinction brings, but we have the total opposite attitude when it comes to humans. And the reason is that we ourselves are human.

Clearly this is a speciesist attitude, with the unusual quality of probably being a good one. Says the self-admitted speciesist. It is very difficult to look at objectively when you are as intimately involved with the issue, as all Homo sapiens are.
__________________
| (• ◡•)|  (❍ᴥ❍ʋ)

Reply With Quote
  #23  
01-26-2008, 09:43 PM
mudling's Avatar
mudling
Outlaw Sniper
 
: Jan 2005
: Sydney
: 1,631
Rep Power: 22
mudling  (123)mudling  (123)

No, I didn't mean that, it's just people like Hobo were saying it doesn't matter, and we shouldn't be arguing over it, and I was just saying I didn't mean for us to have a whole thread dedicated to it, but it's fine by me if it happens.
Obviously people want to argue over it, and so why shouldn't they?
Oh, and as Mistsur was saying, I was going out of my way not to offend anyone, so I brought up the point.
But BM, I was trying to say that race actually means speacies, and we use it a different way.
But this thread is obviously deviating towards the use of politcal correctness or something, so why don't we just make a thread for that? (Strangley enough I'm not being sarcastic)
But if you want to mention it here, I tend to always try and be politcally correct, call me a smart arse, but I either do it as a joke ("I look like a eskimo with this jacket"
"*Hmgh* Hello, they prefer to be called inuits") or as I was earlier, to be polite and not offend anyone, as my generation, expecially my school and freinds, tend to be like that, call us snobs, hence I may occasionally say some snotty or boarderline racist things, and I'm sorry if I offend anyone (Hey, I got a cab full of girls against me once, not nice at all)
__________________


Last edited by mudling; 01-26-2008 at 09:50 PM..
Reply With Quote
  #24  
01-29-2008, 05:07 AM
Mac Sirloin's Avatar
Mac Sirloin
Less worse
 
: Aug 2006
: Exquisite Squalor
: 5,657
Blog Entries: 301
Rep Power: 27
Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)

:
Actually race has two meanings...
1. Like racing with cars, bikes etc.
2. Like human race, alien race...

And if word race is bad for you guys... well we could say species right? xD
I hate you, leave this forum, no one buys this 'Alien' Schtick anymore (not that we ever really did), you're just some 12 year old with self diagnosed ASSBURGERS looking for attention. Fuck off, Alien Magi.
__________________
I see you jockin' me.

Reply With Quote
  #25  
01-29-2008, 05:08 AM
abe is now!'s Avatar
abe is now!
Mafia, Pizza & Mandolino
 
: Jan 2007
: Italy
: 2,825
Blog Entries: 25
Rep Power: 21
abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)

Don't be racist against him, Kastere.
__________________
ain!

Reply With Quote
  #26  
01-29-2008, 05:42 AM
Wings of Fire's Avatar
Wings of Fire
Beautiful Bastard
 
: Dec 2007
: Stafford
: 9,537
Blog Entries: 143
Rep Power: 33
Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)

That is not racism, currently there is no 'ism' for being predisposed towards morons.

Even political correctness wouldn't dare go that far.
__________________
:
“I always believe the movies I've made are smarter than the way they are perceived by sort of mass culture and by the critics,” Snyder said, a statement he immediately followed by saying, “Also, ‘It looks like a video game.’

Reply With Quote
  #27  
01-29-2008, 05:53 AM
abe is now!'s Avatar
abe is now!
Mafia, Pizza & Mandolino
 
: Jan 2007
: Italy
: 2,825
Blog Entries: 25
Rep Power: 21
abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)

I wasn't so serious when I said it, Wings of Fire. Anyway racism is for weak people. I hate them. I was racist, but now I regret it because I change my idea. So I must ask apologyze to OANST. And to everybody (although they are a few) I offended.
__________________
ain!

Reply With Quote
  #28  
01-29-2008, 06:02 AM
Mac Sirloin's Avatar
Mac Sirloin
Less worse
 
: Aug 2006
: Exquisite Squalor
: 5,657
Blog Entries: 301
Rep Power: 27
Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)Mac Sirloin  (7645)

Racism is just one of those issues that people can swarm with PC'edness to seem like a good person. For example, it's alright for black people to call each other nigger but not white people, right? Well, the problem is that it's a matter of perspective; some white people think it'sd funny as hell, but others can go on and on about how derogatory it is without really thinking.
__________________
I see you jockin' me.

Reply With Quote
  #29  
01-29-2008, 06:07 AM
abe is now!'s Avatar
abe is now!
Mafia, Pizza & Mandolino
 
: Jan 2007
: Italy
: 2,825
Blog Entries: 25
Rep Power: 21
abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)abe is now!  (2392)

I was racist against people who came to Italy and dirty everything with their rubbish.
__________________
ain!

Reply With Quote
  #30  
01-29-2008, 06:13 AM
Wings of Fire's Avatar
Wings of Fire
Beautiful Bastard
 
: Dec 2007
: Stafford
: 9,537
Blog Entries: 143
Rep Power: 33
Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)Wings of Fire  (13656)

:
I was racist against people who came to Italy and dirty everything with their rubbish.
Thats nationalism.

Also from the way you typed that it sounds like you still are.
__________________
:
“I always believe the movies I've made are smarter than the way they are perceived by sort of mass culture and by the critics,” Snyder said, a statement he immediately followed by saying, “Also, ‘It looks like a video game.’

Reply With Quote


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 








 
 
- Oddworld Forums - -