Another Goddamn Piracy Discussion

[AlexFili]

The way games were pirated in the late 90s affected some new features in new games. Such as multiplayer modes (regardless of genre), 'always online' social features and DLC. Personally I am fond of DLC because it means if you want a little bit extra of a game, you can get it. I must admit though, I am not fond of DLC which is already on the disc. I much prefer Rock Band DLC where if a brand new song comes out, players can download it for a reasonable price. Hardware consoles now have "firmware" which periodically update to block cheaters and stop roms working.

Pirating movies which are in the cinema seems pointless to me, since you get a washed out picture and bad sound. DVD rips of movies however are much more desirable, and naturally are one of the most downloaded things.

[OANST]

Now that you've explained piracy could you explain to me this Oddworld thing?

[AlexFili]

No problem, you see it all started when I have nothing to write here so I'll just work in binary. 0101010110101010111001110101010111001111010101011100111

1010101011100111101010101101010101110011110101010111001111100111110101010111001110111001110101010111 0011010101011100111111010101011110101010111001111010101011100111001111010101011100111101010101110011 1101010101110011110101010111001111

[MA]

pirate pirate ARRRRR ME HEARTYS
SHIVER ME TIMBERS AND A BOTTLE O' RUM

i do that all the time. piracy is great.

[Laser]

Man fuck piracy

[OANST]

Attaboy.

[MA]

Man fuck piracy

right on.

straight edge forever.

[Nepsotic]

Man fuck? Ew.

[Wings of Fire]

Men? Ewww

Cartoon ponies? Yay!

[Strike Witch]

Piracy huh?

I always get stuck between Gruier and Grunhilde.

[SpAM_CAN]

Best reason for pirating anything:

[OANST]

Best reason for pirating anything:

I promise you. I PROMISE you that this never plays a part in a person's decision to steal movies. This is merely another way for the thief to tell themself that what they are doing is okay. Which is bullshit.

[Manco]

It also misses off several steps before “insert DVD”.

Such as “find download that is not a virus, is well-seeded and is of decent quality” and “wait several hours for download to finish”.

[OANST]

It also misses off several steps before “insert DVD”.

Such as “find download that is not a virus, is well-seeded and is of decent quality” and “wait several hours for download to finish”.

It does seem to miss that part, yeah. But when someone is trying as hard as they can to justify their clearly unethical behavior, niceties such as "honesty" are usually left at the side of the road.

[Crashpunk]

I can honestly say I hate DVD menus with a passion. But it's not something I would pirate a film for just so I can avoid them.

Off-topic: I also hate those "You wouldn't steal a car, so why would you steal a film?" messages.

[MeechMunchie]

Off-topic: I also hate those "You wouldn't steal a car, so why would you steal a film?" messages.

Obligatory.

[Varrok]

It's a stupid campaign. How the hell could they know I wouldn't steal a car, eh?!

[Laser]

I've never seen the correlation between stealing a car and stealing a film. You aren't directly damaging someone's life by downloading Fast Five, for example. Unlike if you were to steal someone's car or purse.

[Wings of Fire]

Ho boy

[MeechMunchie]

Here we go again!

*Comedy jingle*

[Jordan]

Best reason for pirating anything: (STUPID PICTURE)

That is honestly the worst attempt at trying to justify the pirating of DVDs I have ever seen.

[OANST]

That is honestly the worst attempt at trying to justify the pirating of DVDs I have ever seen.

I don't know. Havoc's reason of "It isn't any good, so I'm going to steal it" was pretty mind blowing. But yeah, that picture was dumb as shit.

[MeechMunchie]

It's not as bad as the pig one. Wait a sec



Oh Christ. I once wrote an entire essay on all of the things wrong with that image.

[Hazz-JB]

The problem is that illegal downloading isn't just a few bad apples actively seeking to screw over hard working people, it's more like an inevitable result caused by the accepted definition of "theft" (and all the usual implications it carries) being applied to a medium in which it isn't compatible.

The arguments justifying piracy are simplistic because they stick to the way people naturally think about theft, ie. theft = depriving someone else of their property for your own gain. The vast majority of people aren't going to adapt their moral systems to the relatively new possibilities of the internet in such a short space of time, and the producers of the products being pirated have for the most part none nothing to adapt to the situation in a sensible manner, choosing to punish pirates and paying customers alike instead of creating a business model which actually works on the internet.

[OANST]

What business model would that be?

[Hazz-JB]

Well, it might be bringing up an entirely different debate, but treating digital media as a service instead of a product seems to have worked for things like Steam and Netflix. I'm not saying those have solved the issue of piracy completely, and I know some people dislike Steam for various reasons, but those companies are at least treating the internet like a new marketplace rather than a problem that they wish would go away.

[OANST]

It's a fair point that making everything available through these services may help some, but a lot companies do this already, and their products still get pirated. However, I do think that the business model of subscription services probably is the most viable solution to this problem.

We have to understand though, that it's difficult for a company who is having their product stolen thousands of times a day to not want to penalize someone for this. They will eventually have to find better ways of dealing with this, but let's just not forget that they aren't really the problem here, and that they didn't create the situation. New internet morality is just another way of justifying faulty ethics, and is not a reasonable excuse.

[Alcar]

I have not read a single post in this thread - this response is virgin.

I cannot condone piracy

Alcar....

[skychase2rebirth]

When I download music, I listen to it first. Then, if it's good I'll buy the cd (even if I never listen to it again) and if it's bad, I'll delete it. I do the same with video games (ps1), I had a lot of copies when I was a kid but now that I have money, I'm trying to buy them all, even if I never play them. A donation system would be great for musicians.

[OANST]

Raise your hand if you believe these stories.