:
Also, Episode 2 The Phantom Edit was so much better than the original E2. They cut a lot of nonsense.
|
I quite enjoyed the fan edit of The Hobbit, maybe I’ll give some Star Wars fan edits a shot sometime. They can’t be any worse than the original Prequels, right?
I watched Arrival earlier; it’s a pretty interesting take on how the first contact with aliens could go. It felt pretty grounded to me, with how everyone is so on edge for possible attack and completely in the dark about how to even communicate with the aliens.
It was shorter than I expected, which was actually a pleasant surprise since it didn’t stretch the story out too thin and overstay its welcome. I think my only criticism would be for the ending:
The tension as the different human factions broke off contact and prepared to attack worked very well, but the way in which the protagonist succeeds in understanding the aliens’ message and then defusing the situation comes across as a little too deus ex machina to me; I think I would have preferred the climax to have been rooted more in the efforts to translate and come to understand the aliens, which was an interesting process to watch. But I suppose that the ending
wouldn’t have had so much emotional impact without its twist, so I can live with that.