Yay, I can post
For your various Fan Fic ideas, I have a few things that might turn out well (or not):
For one, maybe there could be a selective panel to judge Fan FIcs. Maybe a non Fan Fic writer (to think about enjoyment value), a fellow Fan Fic writer (to think about how well its written, and to maybe give a few critiques), and one of our mods (probably Al). I think this would work well, to get an all around feel for judging ideas from all aspects.
Second is relating to artwork. Here a panel might also be well, following the same pattern. A non or average artist (for an overall "nice look"), a more in debth artist (to think about different drawing aspects, and critiques), and a mod (probably Alector). For me saying "probably XXX" for the two mod panel parts, I'm stongly considering who is more adept for that kind of fan work.
Now, relating to everything. This may be a bad idea, but could there be a Sub-Forum for the few elite Fics and artwork judged as outstanding? For instance, all completely finished Fan Fics, or individual artwork pieces/prepared threads for serious critiquing. For the Fan Fics, I'm thinking about competely typed through documents for people to read as a full novel and critique. For individual pieces, and example owuld be Middle Boogies picture of a Glukkon that was a while back. Prepared threads, as in multiple pieces that are designed for judging.
Yes, my thread is very long and very boring for most, but I'm thinking of a well organized Fan Corner.