Well, I was talking about the cartoonish sound effects edited into that Ted scene video. Not the Ted scene itself because it's perfect.
What I'm getting here is that the burp sound in the original wasn't all that audible so when they made it more audible in NnT it stands out, feels wrong, doesn't seem to fit. Since we've spent 17 years seeing that scene in a very particular way. And the guys as JAW probably didn't know that we didn't know. The burping doesn't seem at all to be an example of moving the game further and further down the goofy void. But just making a sound effect actually noticeable.
A burping grinder doesn't really seem to be a matter of subtlety.
I mean if the roles were reversed, the burp was really noticeable in the original and the cliff sound effects weren't really noticeable I imagine you'd see the same complaint.
I can accept the argument that you like the less noticeable version of the original better but the idea that the burp is absolute nonsense and proving that NnT is close to MO reborn seems a bit silly to me.
|