[El Dango AGAIN]

I see where the atmosphere argument is coming from, and I'd agree if it wasn't for Necrum, which is amazing in this regard. Exoddus has less natural areas though, so it makes sense that people would prefer Oddysee.

I really love both, and I think they compliment each other nicely, but I'm leaning towards Exoddus for its improvements in gameplay, most of all quicksaving.