[MeechMunchie]

Okay, I've finished Beyond Good & Evil, 100% for pearls and photos.

I liked:
The music (Propa-ganda...)
The DomZ design
The photography element, and the way your photos get used in the reports
Shooting A-S air tanks
The name Pey'j (it sounds like something a pig would call themselves)
Flying the Beluga
Peepers (I like cool guys with big noses)
That nice walrus fellow
The endings (both of them), in a sort of hilariously cack-handed way.

I didn't like:
The controls (unhook and grab seemed randomly interchangeable)
The camera angles (seriously screwy, especially the way they change)
The level design (dull)
The fact that they wouldn't let Pey'j stay dead
The creepy jokes about eating pork WITH A SAPIENT PIG
The whole "botched port" feeling

It was okay, better than most, but certainly not as good as I had been led to believe.

EDIT: Oh, and I really liked: That disc-flinging mini-game. They should make that shit fo' realz.