I have to say I prefer the one
without shading. If shading isn't done very carefully, it just makes the picture look worse. Especially if it's pillow-shading.
I've done pixel-art, I know about shading, and I probably could make this look 3Dish, but I think it looks damned good how it is. And I don't want to mess with Crashpunk's pictures.
Well done Crash
