Well, I think it's a good idea, but the fact that someone can start an account a long time ago, and then post over 30 or so and leave, and then come back ten years later or something and have a huge ammount of stars.
I'm happy with the second idea though, I see how this could work, how about a seperate star system though, stars above being for posts, and stars below being for years, if not, you could put them together, and have say greyed out stars for posts, and non greyed out stars for years.
Or is that what some of you meant?
__________________
|