Oddworld Forums

Oddworld Forums (http://www.oddworldforums.net/index.php)
-   Off-Topic Discussion (http://www.oddworldforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=9)
-   -   UK General Election thread (http://www.oddworldforums.net/showthread.php?t=19180)

Wings of Fire 04-23-2010 11:37 AM

UK General Election thread
 
What the BNP plan to do
  • Deport foreigners convicted of crimes in Britain, regardless of immigration status, ban the burka and building of mosques. Deport radical Islamist preachers
  • Increase UK Border Agency funding, withdraw from EU, repeal Race Relations Act and scrap Equalities and Human Rights Commission. Scrap ID cards
  • Review the Police and Criminal Evidence Act to remove unnecessary bureaucracy from police duties
  • Reintroduce capital punishment for drug dealers, child murderers, multiple murderers, murderers of policemen on duty and terrorists
  • Reintroduce right of householders to defend themselves and their property, "using whatever means they deem necessary"
  • Establish penal station for "extremely dangerous/violent repeat criminals", including rapists, on the British island of South Georgia

Meanwhile the Scottish National Party claim that British politicians need to realize that Britain is made up of four countries, not one.

What about those election debates then?

MeechMunchie 04-23-2010 11:41 AM

Old Labour died with Europop, so I'm rooting for Cleggy this year. Or Alan "Howlin' Laud" Hope.

Wings of Fire 04-23-2010 11:42 AM

Clegg sounds nice, although he already has his internet backlash. Apparently people only support him because it's cool.

MA 04-23-2010 12:02 PM

i've been doing a bit of reading up on the web, and watched the news more than usual to decide who to vote for. i decided this morning that i'm gonna vote Clegg.

otherwise it would have been the Monster Raving Loony Party. :tard:

MeechMunchie 04-23-2010 12:08 PM

:

()
Old Labour died with Europop, so I'm rooting for Cleggy this year. Or Alan "Howlin' Laud" Hope.

:

()
i've been doing a bit of reading up on the web, and watched the news more than usual to decide who to vote for. i decided this morning that i'm gonna vote Clegg.

otherwise it would have been the Monster Raving Loony Party. :tard:

I think we might be the same person. Or multis of each other.

MA 04-23-2010 12:17 PM

oh yeah, i forgot that was his name.

shaman 04-23-2010 02:21 PM

That's what the BNP are planning to do? Hello vote.

Oh wait. I can't fucking vote.

used:) 04-23-2010 02:37 PM

Lol, wow, Shaman fucking sucks balls.

If that dreadful party has actually gained some substantial ground, then I am no longer ashamed to come from the country where the Ku Klux Klan originated.

shaman 04-23-2010 02:45 PM

Oh come now, i was being facetious.

OddjobAbe 04-23-2010 02:46 PM

I agree with Used. Shaman's support of the BNP sickens me. The only reason they're gaining a little bit of popularity among some people is because of the state Labour's got us into. The BNP are fucking shithouses.

EDIT: Shaman beat me.

used:) 04-23-2010 02:48 PM

:

()
Oh come now, i was being facetious.

Who says I was referring to your post? ;)

shaman 04-23-2010 02:49 PM

:

()
Who says I was referring to your post? ;)

Oh alright then. Glad we understand each other.

Havoc 04-23-2010 03:45 PM

:

Deport foreigners convicted of crimes in Britain, regardless of immigration status, ban the burka and building of mosques. Deport radical Islamist preachers
I support this, actually. Though the phrasing is a bit weird in this case.

Wings of Fire 04-23-2010 03:47 PM

:

()
I support this, actually. Though the phrasing is a bit weird in this case.

You support banning the creation of new places of worship?

STM 04-23-2010 03:54 PM

Shame Lord Much is dead!

Havoc 04-23-2010 03:56 PM

I don't like religion, but that has nothing to do with this particular case. I think that the position of Islam in Europe is taking rather weird and sometimes even dangerous forms.

For one the entire Islamic culture is starting to take over the native cultures of European countries (there is a very similar problem over here in the Netherlands). When politicians start thinking about making Arabic a standard taught language next to English and German in pre- and high-school, that is where I draw the line. I've been seeing a disturbing trend with many countries where the host country has to adapt to the guests it provides shelter for. It's supposed to be the other way around.

Secondly, there is a very real problem of extremist preachers in Mosques. We've got a few over here as well but for some reason they can't be arrested for it. Apparently it's fine to ask your followers to kill everyone who was born in the western world. Not saying that's a reason not to build more Mosques, but there should at least be the option to close one down if there are messages like this being proclaimed there.

STM 04-23-2010 04:05 PM

Ban them and there mosques lest er I mean unless they have a degree

Wings of Fire 04-23-2010 04:07 PM

:

()
For one the entire Islamic culture is starting to take over the native cultures of European countries (there is a very similar problem over here in the Netherlands). When politicians start thinking about making Arabic a standard taught language next to English and German in pre- and high-school, that is where I draw the line. I've been seeing a disturbing trend with many countries where the host country has to adapt to the guests it provides shelter for. It's supposed to be the other way around.

I don't understand why any of this is a problem.

shaman 04-23-2010 04:07 PM

:

()
I don't understand why any of this is a problem.

Just as i suspected.

Wings of Fire 04-23-2010 04:11 PM

What's so wrong with having to learn Arabic?
What's so wrong about respecting the practices of our neighbors?
What's so important and rigid about our culture?

OddjobAbe 04-23-2010 05:18 PM

:

()
What's so wrong with having to learn Arabic?
What's so wrong about respecting the practices of our neighbors?
What's so important and rigid about our culture?

Absolutely nothing, but it is a point of principle. It seems to me that these neighbours don't give a damn about our own customs and what have you, and I feel that if our culture is shit and meaningless, so is their culture. At the end of the day, the people who are arguing against the catering of these foreigners are just trying to protect their way of life. They feel threatened by the fact that these people are coming over here and are reproducing, thus increasing the amount of people who live slightly differently to themselves. In reality, neither culture is going to be greater than the other. There will merely be an alternative, but I can understand that people feel their culture strongly influences the way that they live, and so wish to protect what they are familiar with.

Josh 04-23-2010 11:41 PM

I knew the BNP were bad, but FUCK, that's some nasty stuff.

Havoc 04-24-2010 02:06 AM

:

()
What's so wrong with having to learn Arabic?
What's so wrong about respecting the practices of our neighbors?
What's so important and rigid about our culture?

Like what OddjobAbe said, it's a matter of principle over anything else. When you move away from your own country and you settle down in a completely different country it's only natural that you try and adapt yourself to the customs and standards of that country. The very last thing you should demand from the country that was nice enough to take you in is that they change everything to fit your needs.

Don't get me wrong, all those things are fine on their own.

There's nothing wrong with learning Arabic on your own initiative. But it is wrong if your government wants to make it a standard because the foreigners who came here 12 years ago simply refuse to learn the native language. Visitors adapt to the place they visit, not the other way around.

And in the specific case of Islam I don't think I want to respect their practices. It may be normal in Iran or where-ever that you use your wife as a slave all day long and order her around like a dog and treat her as such, but in the western world we actually have such a thing as human rights. When I hear about Islamic men refusing to shake hands with women and then complaining about how they can't find a job at a legal firm, I don't exactly feel sympathy for those people.

So yeah, it's principle. That doesn't mean one should leave his entire religion behind, but when things do start to bump heads it's the visitor who should adapt. If he doesn't like how things go in the country where he is a guest he's free to leave. Until then he should adapt.

shaman 04-24-2010 02:21 AM

I agree with pretty much everthing in Havoc's post.

MA 04-24-2010 04:20 AM

:

()
What's so wrong with having to learn Arabic?

this is the only problem i have. French was bad enough. fuck language.

Munch's Master 04-24-2010 04:22 AM

I agree with a lot of what Havoc says, however I'll say this: I am willing to respect Islamic practices provided they aren't infringing on peoples human rights. Which is whhy I dislike the burka. The hajib is a part of their religion and I have zero problem with Islamic women wearing one if they choose, but the Burka isn't required by the Qur'an, and is just a symbol of the female discrimination that has lingered in elements of Islamic culture.

When I go to Spain on holiday I make an effort to speak Spanish as much as possible: it's their country & culture so I should respect their customs. I hate going to the "English ghetto" type places (Note: when I use the term ghetto I mean it as a concentration of a particular ethnicity, not as a poor/run down area),where you get all this chavvish culture and little actual Spanish culture. You put the customs of your host first, not the other way round. When in Rome and all that. A perfect example is a friend of mine who recently informed me he was Islamic. He doesn't drink, doesn't smoke, I think he might attend the mosque, and he might know Arabic (I've only ever heard him speak English, however). However he never tries to impose his faith on others: he's a perfect example of how its fully compatible to be Islamic AND western British. If you're religious then that is great, but there's no need to impose your faith onto others, whatever your religion. Just to answer Joe's post:
:

()
What's so wrong with having to learn Arabic?
What's so wrong about respecting the practices of our neighbors?
What's so important and rigid about our culture?

1- Nothing wrong with learning Arabic if you choose to. But the guest follows the host's customs first, not the other way round. Suppose I was at a friend's house and he was drinking beer, and I say "Hey, you've got to drink this too" and try to make him drink some wine, that's not fair on him. However if I go "Want to try this?" and he accepts, then all's well. Common courtesy to your host.
2-Absolutely nothing at all, but respecting your neighbour's practices doesn't mean having to adopt their practices in place of your own.
3-Nothing but by the samme token what's so important and rigid about THEIRS? I've noticed a trend in society recently that seems to be of a "You arent important but everyone different is" mentality. I saw an article in a papeer where the columnist was labelling white British people as lazy, alcoholic, theiving scroungers, and all immigrants as saints. If that had been the other way round it would be banned. I've got absolutely zero problem with any other cultures comnig to Britain provided they're willing to integrate. If they respect our traditions and don't try to infringe, I'll completely respect theirs and won't infringe either.

I firmly disagree with banning the building of mosques- they have every right to worship. Also, on deporting radical preachers: that depends whether all radical preachers are going to be stopped or just the Islamic ones. If the latter then that's not exactly fair. I don't want to hear them spouting such inflammtory extremism, but you can't ban them and then still allow radical Christian puritans, say, to also spread intolerance.

Capital punishment I feel has its merits but also its major disadvantages. You can't just apply it to a crime category, you've got to look at individual cases. Harold Shipman for instance was a complete monster, however a guy who murders someone because they'd I dunno, pickpocketed him or nicked his missus- while it's still a dreadful act, isn't really on the same level. And I don't know about giving it to drug dealers-would it be just the crime lords, or would it be to Johnny Marijuana who flogs a few joints on the weekend too? As for terrorism, if you execute them you just create a martyr for their cause. It's no coincidence that they use suicide bombings. As for a penal station....eh, I'm not so sure. We're overcrowded here sure, but again I'm just concerned about the selection criteria and specific details.

I'd never vote BNP for 3 reasons: 1) I think several policies go too far, and several aren't outlined clearly 2) I don't trust Nick Griffin at alll and would be very concerned that he would become more radical if in power, and 3) Even if the BNP did tone things down, cut out the objectionable policies and replace Nick Griffin, the stigma of them being a racist party won't go away and a vote with them associates you with all kinds of unpleasant people.

I'm torn between voting Conservative & voting Green Party. 2 very different parties I know. I have no interest in voting Labour, while I like elements of the Lib Dems (Mostly Vince Cable & repealing the Digital Economy bill), I have issue with more of their policies than with Green or Tory. Green will never get in though, so I'm unsure what to do.

Never intended this post to last so long. I'm done now, I think.

Wings of Fire 04-24-2010 04:38 AM

:

()
I agree with a lot of what Havoc says, however I'll say this: I am willing to respect Islamic practices provided they aren't infringing on peoples human rights. Which is whhy I dislike the burka. The hajib is a part of their religion and I have zero problem with Islamic women wearing one if they choose, but the Burka isn't required by the Qur'an, and is just a symbol of the female discrimination that has lingered in elements of Islamic culture.

Islamic culture != Quoran. See later point about catching more flies with honey than vinegar.
:

1- Nothing wrong with learning Arabic if you choose to. But the guest follows the host's customs first, not the other way round.
If a lot of people in your country speak Arabic as a first language then it's only a sign of the times that schools should consider putting them in the curriculum. Frankly it's far more important and necessary to learn as a foriegn language than French or German.
:

2-Absolutely nothing at all, but respecting your neighbour's practices doesn't mean having to adopt their practices in place of your own.
If you were a guest in my house then I would do my best to understand and respect what you do and how you behave, if you were living in my house then even more so. It's my responsibility as a host who invited you in to look after you the best I can.
:

3-Nothing but by the samme token what's so important and rigid about THEIRS?
Ever heard the fable of the North Wind and the Sun? Right now Islam is towing a reactionary defensive line. The best way to make them accept us is for us first to accept them.

shaman 04-24-2010 04:51 AM

:

()

If you were a guest in my house then I would do my best to understand and respect what you do and how you behave, if you were living in my house then even more so. It's my responsibility as a host who invited you in to look after you the best I can.

You haven't answered the question. Would you or would you not forsake the other inhabitants of your house whose ways are similar to yours for the sake of a minority?

I'm not saying they should "like it or lump it" We should be a comforting as possible for them without harming other people's culture. But if you want to talk about acceptance, it must work both ways. So, i will ask you again. Would you agree with the displacement of one people's way of life for the sake of a minority visitor?

Wings of Fire 04-24-2010 04:55 AM

:

()
You haven't answered the question. Would you or would you not forsake the other inhabitants of your house whose ways are similar to yours for the sake of a minority?

I'm not saying they should "like it or lump it" We should be a comforting as possible for them without harming other people's culture. But if you want to talk about acceptance, it must work both ways. So, i will ask you again. Would you agree with the displacement of one people's way of life for the sake of a minority visitor?

I'd compromise. I'd let them do as they please in my house as long as it doesn't hurt the other inhabitants.

shaman 04-24-2010 05:03 AM

:

()
I'd compromise. I'd let them do as they please in my house as long as it doesn't hurt the other inhabitants.

Welcome to my list of favorite people. How does it feel? Dirty all over?

Also, who are you? And what have you done with WoF?