'Why should I? Is it that far beyond ordinary that the politicians would orchestrate a killing for political motivations?'

I think the more likely reason is that some random faction has posed as this random guy for publicity.

'The killing was a result of how shabbily the Iraqi prisoners were kept.'

That's what they say, but i'm sure if the Iraqi's were been treated well in prisons they would be beheading the guy because the coalition is in Iraq. They would've found a reason whatever.

That's why America were just about the WORST country to help, because everyone hates America.

To be honest, I think people only beleive that the guy who was killed wasn't the real guy because that is what they WANT to beleive. But really, it quite clearly is him. I've seen both the entire film footage, and then footage shot in his house, looking at a photograph of him - the guy looks identical.

Also, how would the extremists know who this guy is to fake his death? They got this supposed "fake" to say who he was, don't you think it's a bit of a coincidence that they managed to find someone who looks EXACTLY like this guy, AND know ALL about him?

ALSO, he doesn't look a single bit like an Iraqi or a dummy. He moves about, walks, talks, and his eyes move. And he was killed. The entire footage doesn't break anywhere, it's continuous from start to finish, meaning at no point could they replace the guy with a dummy.

What motivations? Thanks for the softball, Death. President Bush is logging his lowest approval ratings ever and has a tremendous scandal on his hands. Does he need a little smoke cover? Does he need a little breathing room? Do he NEED people to be "patriotic" and not realize how badly the situation in Iraq is right now? Yes, yes, and yes. This is the perfect way to get the attention of of his incompetency and bungles and unto hating some ragheads in the name of FREEDOM(tm).
Nobody knows what they wear. How about the federal government and countless others who've noticed the bullshit gold ring and two legs? You can also clearly see the guys are wearing flakk jackets. They are also wearing black and are hooded. The man on the far right is wearing white tennis shoes. How much more ****ing detail do I have to tell you so that you believe I've actually seen the tapes and pictures that can be found freely all across the internet and just about every major news publication in exsistence?

So far you haven't really given any good reasons. Or proven that it's a fake.

And I still see no motivations for Bush to arrange something like this. The killing was because of US incompedence with the prisoners, it doesn't make sense to me why bush would be a more likely person to do this than a volatile nation like iraq...

I am not saying that I think Bush or federal cronies did it. I'm just saying that it seems pretty phony to me and it deserves more scrutiny.

Well... at least SOMEBODY died in that video... if it wasn't this guy then who the fuck was it?

I'm iffy on the subject of the whole thing being a hoax. While I believe it's entirely in America's capability, I don't know in my mind for sure. It just goes to show that everything we are fed could be false. Our history books are certainly flawed.

Alcar...