Re: Vegetarianism
:
I really don't see why you are attacking meat eaters anyway, what do you indeed to accomplish by trying to make us feel guilty about what we eat? You have been consuming alcohol, and smoking weed and cigarettes before you were over the legal age right? You don't see me criticizing you about it, what you want do consume is entirely up to you no one else. |
Using drugs affects only you - nothing dies needlessly in the process. And secondary smoke doesn't count if smokers are responsible enough. The 'lecture' is somewhat justified because carnivores result in the death of creatures - it's not a belief, but a fact.
I'm inclined to say that Sydney did come on a little harsh, but this sort of argument won't have any effect if it's passive and neutral. |
:
|
:
:
:
ZombieX covered paramiteabe's post, so I'll skip it. :
:
:
|
:
There are some people who don't know better too! Your saying that all humans know better? What about rapist? Murders? Theives? Your saying that they know better? If they do, then why do those things? P.S., not all animals kill their food. Have you ever heard of scavengers who feed on dead animals? :
Also, I don't eat that much beef. ANd Dan, when Stat talk about take care of your own health, he meant to worry about YOUR OWN health and not the health of other people. P.s, sorry if I edit too much. |
When you move out of home things get easier. After I got my own place I found that the price of meat sort of dictated my diet - and so I've mainly lived on vegetables dishes and bread as a snack.
How about fish, though? I know it's generally not considered a meat because many people see them on the same level as plants, but that shouldn't necessarily dictate their fate. |
Yeah I love fish also. Fish is quite healthy.
|
:
:
|
Oo... too many posts. I read almost everything, but I'm only going to answer PinkHaired now...
:
:
:
You have ? Well, good for you, then… :
:
:
:
:
:
:
What is your point in this, again? Actually, that's a lot better, than killing the animals yourself. :
:
:
|
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
|
Not to be a downer, Faz, but finnish food without meat isn't traditional unless the finnish fod didn't have meat in it to begin with.
I don't see what the hooplah is about. And their definately is hooplah, dammit! I can smell hooplah a mile away! So, what you vegetarians are trying to do is make us your bretheren. I don't see how calling meat eaters greedy and just generally being bitches about the topic is going to convert anyone.Im sorry for calling you names and insulting your beliefs as happy horseshit. I won't call it happy horseshit as long as you lay off the name calling and insulting too! |
:
:
Yes, I read your post correctly... So you're saying that you don't have to eat meat to stay healthy, but you need to eat it for nutrition? Aren't they the same thing? I meen... if you want to stay healthy, you have to eat like nutrition tells you. So I don't get what you mean with this... I know you don't eat meat alone. I already said it in my previous post. Of course you don't eat just meat. Why on earth would I think something like that?! :
:
:
:
:
:
:
|
:
1: I do have respect for those I eat...they enable me to feed my body so I can live for another day. The same with any other meat eating animal. 2: I don't eat meat for pleasure. Yes it tastes good to me, but I consume it for the same reason I stated in number 1 Now...this next part may not seem to belong in this topic...but it will give you and idea of the where and how I stand on this issue. (apologies in advance for anything in the following that offends you) If meat products have no nutritional value that can't be gained from plant matter, then why isn't there a wide spread push in human society to stop eating meat? Because the majority of the human race sees eating meat as much a part of our daily lives as it was for our ancestors. Technically...we are not even supposed to be consuming dairy products beyond infancy, as our adult bodies are not designed to be able to digest it, but do we stop in this day and age? No. The problem is that due to our advancement...humans as a majority are more concerned with living as long as possible...to beat death as long as possible, rather then live as a part of nature as we did thousands of years ago. With the exception of a few scattered human tribes that have followed the old ways for generations, humans are no longer living as an actual part of nature. Instead we are forcing it to bend to our wills, destroying it in the process. Yes I disagree with how we 'get' the steaks to our table and I would love it to be done in a more 'natural' way. But we are too engrained in the 'unnatural' way of obtaining our food. Not only that but the humans as a race have grown too lazy and unfit to survive out in the wild like the rest of our fellow animals. Too often now the weak has survived to procreate...and our gene pool is polluted and weakened as a result. Yes...we are advancing to a point where we can 'fix' those genetic problems, but my point is that we should have never have had a need to do that in the first place, if we had continued to follow the way of our ancestors. Our intelligence has gotten us this far, but it is also a curse in this regard. Yes...I am against human progress (as it was hinted at in my 'medicine' example in my first post on this topic)...and I know I am probably one of the very few that believe this way. So, yes...I have a very 'unique' outlook on the human race. What the hell does this all have to do with this topic? Well my point is that if we weren't so dependent on our own technological advances for everything in our daily lives...we wouldn't be having this discussion. I eat meat because it is what nature intended me to eat as an omnivore. If I were to only eat plants...I would have been born a rabbit or some other 'prey' animal. Yes we are the most intelligent life form on this planet that we know of...but that doesn't mean we should deny our nature, for we are still animals like all the others. Eat what you want, perhaps when you pass from this life the powers that be will get it right next time and have you reborn as a pure herbivore. Yes...I most likely offended a lot of vegetarians and vegans with that last sentence, but is true. If we were meant to only eat one way...we would have been made that way. (like the 'if humans were meant to fly they would have been born with wings' bit) Just because we have a brain and a sense of 'morals' doesn't mean we shouldn't act as nature intended. We still do in many instances, though in a 'round about way'. We fight each other over territory and resources for instance.(The only difference is that since we are intelligent we can think of more 'creative' ways to fight for it (oh like guns, bombs, etc...We are even getting to the point were we can send robots in to fight for us.)). We 'migrate' when the whether turns cold in winter...and return when spring comes. (if you don't believe that you obviously never been to Florida and experienced the influx of retires in winter) We are nothing but animals with a large brain, with the unique ability to actually think, create, and modify our environment. One more thing for this rant: You invited us meat eaters to go kill our own food. Well, lets be fair now...I invite you to go gather your own fruits and veggies in the wilderness (no...your garden doesn't count). If the only way you will accept our meat eating ways is for us to kill it ourselves...then you go gather your own food like us. If you can't do that...then sit down and shut up about it. Yes I am being harsh here...but that is in response to your own harshness toward us. *sits back and waits for the flames* |
Well, I've read almost all of this argument. Since I can't really be botherd to particapate in the discussion, I will only put my point of view foward. . .
Eating meat isn't wrong. I only don't eat meat because of the way the animals are kept, and the way they are slaughterd. The only meat I do eat is Tuna (and I don't eat very much of it), because suffocating to death is better then being ripped to shreads from limb to limb while still alive. I addmitedly eat Tuna purely for selfish reasons, since I don't need to eat it. Also, recently I've been trying to ween myself off of ordinary cows milk, and onto organic milk and soya milk. The way they produce ordinary cows milk isn't very nice, since they take the calves away from thier mothers. I don't think they take the calves away from the cows on the organic farms, but I'm not too sure. I'm gonna go find out for myself soon, though. I also eat cheese, which is another dairy product. And yes, I only eat cheese for selfish reasons. Oh, and I never eat eggs if they aren't free range. Anyway, I belive that you probably should go and hunt and kill the animal yourself before you eat it, and kill it in a humane way. I'd do it, but I don't because: 1. There isn't anything to hunt around here, save for grey squirrels, foxes and wood pidgeons (Ugh! :sick: ). 2. I don't need to. There are plenty of vegatarian products for sale everywhere, so I can get enough nutrition off of them. 3. I've been vegatarian all my life, and I'm not used to meat. I think thats about it. - DH |
:
That last comment was below the belt, and yes it is entirely up to you what you want to consume along as it's ready to be eaten or smoked ect ect... Stop trying to make your self feel good about your diet by attacking meat eaters. |
Its interesting. Fruit and Veg are plants and plants are living beings also...yet people are willing to eat them because they dont show no emotion etc.
On a different note Marijuana comes from a plant and thus was a concious being. Who knows whether plants can think or not...nobody knows for certain. Its basically like saying "This Rock is not alive" how do we know? Just because it doesn't have a heart etc doesn't mean its not alive. People assume to much...and when brought up with certain points they disregard them, thinking their way is right etc or ethicly correct. I dont have a prob with meat eaters, i dont agree with the slaughter of certain animals however and the way that they are killed. I personally believe that to be wrong, if the animal feels pain...i dont like it. But i wont give up eating something just because its hurting the animal. |
Vitamin K is a fat-soluble vitamin that plays an important role in blood clotting
:
:
Eating meat to me is not wrong. It's fine unless you abuse it, yeah then it is bad. I mean c'mon, you probably have eaten a hamburger once in a blue mood. Or once in your lifetime. Can you resist the mouth-watering temptation? I mean, some veggies give in. Your not going to be a perfect veggie all the time. |
:
(Just incase my tone of voice doesn't get through there i have rated that sentence a 'S' for Sarcasm.) |
:
:
:
:
:
Cornelius: We shouldn't visit the moon because we will squash the invisible unicorns living there! Penelope: But there are no invisible unicorns on the moon! Cornelius: But nobody knows for certain... The burden of proof remains with you. Take a class in biology before you claim that plants have feelings. |
Syd my last post was just to let you know the basis of how and why I feel eating meat is ok. I would rant more on that, but what I was saying there is a whole other topic in on itself...and I can promise you it wouldn't be a popular one. (BTW I am surprised no one has commented on the article I posted in my first post on this topic)
Here is something to think about in regards to plants. You can have a perfectly healthly and thriving planet in the yard. Yet when you transplant it to a new location it goes into a state of shock and can possiblely die. No, a plant can't feel pain like we do...but the fact they can go into shock must mean something.... |
Okay, I remember this topic in bits and pieces, and I can't be bothered quoting you all... plus it would make my post look twice as long, which isn't pretty.
At some point it was mentioned that you can't become a vegetarian whilst living with your parents. This sounds to me like you have a very oppressive regime in your household. Surely when you are shopping with them you could pick up some preffered meat substitutes... or if you don't shop with them just do it yourself. Tell them you don't wan't to eat meat, explain why, and move on. Unless you are completely lazy and just let your parents do EVERYTHING for you. Someone also said that vegetarians should go out and pick their own vegetables... I can do that, I've done that. But it misses the point of why you were asked if you could slaughter your own food. (Which I've witnessed, and could not do, by the way). It takes another kind of mental strength to take away another life. As for the general slaughter being painless, you couldn't be more wrong. Cows are herded happlessly and helplessly to the slaughter house. A bolt is swiftly shot into their head before they're strung up and bled etc. You try having a bolt shot in your head. In a recent investigation a number of American slaughterhouses were discovered to have LIVE cows strung up: the bolt didn't kill them... I can't remember the exact details, but if you're desperate I'm sure I could root out the article. The difference between animals and plants is that animals have CONSCIOUSNESS.. a brain. Humans, also having a consciousness, can sympathize with other animals. Anyways, I won't go further down that road. :
Okay, that was a bad analogy... but look at it this way, a lot of you eat meat, right? If YOU knew plant matter contains all the same nutritional values as meat, would you stop eating meat? If the answer was yes, you'd better stop now. Anyways I'm not really putting myself accross clearly here. :
Well, I'll shut up now. I've found this topic very interesting. I've also seen some stupid, arrogant, ignorant, selfish, hypocritical, commendable, original, clever and downright weird views from both "sides" of the debate. It's a pity some people have taken it so personally. God I sound like a moron don't I? One more pointless observation, totally unrelated, and I mean no offence by this, but: :
Anyways, I'm rambling now. :( |
:
|
:
I was basically saying that before veggies have a go at meateaters and vice versa to take into consideration that everything we eat, smoke, drink etc will have come from a living thing. And it is not absurd to believe that all living things have feelings...and thus, whatever we eat, drink, smoke etc we will be having something killed. |
Everything? Even water? And salt?
Then again, they are the only two consunables I can think of that haven't come from a living thing. But I really don't think plants have any mental abilities. For one thing they have no brain, no ganglia and no nervous system. Their ability to sense stimuli such as light and water and their ability to react by growing towards them are achieved chamically rather than electrically, and any plant that does move itself (venus flytraps, for instance) do so by unavoidable mechanism, not decision. But then again, it's entirely possible that their exists a soul that can exist despite the limits of the physical world. I just don't believe it. And rocks being capable of thought is just silly. |
:
|
:
:
:
*argh* :
:
:
:
:
*mmm... the mouth-watering tempation... something smells good* :p *goes off to eat veggie-risotto, which she just cooked for herself* |
:
:
Vitamin A; Orange and yellow vegetables and fruits; dark-green leafy vegetables; whole milk, cream, egg yolks and butter; and animal livers, fish liver oils, garlic, and alfalfa. Vitamin B (complex at least); meats, fish, poultry, brewer's yeast, eggs, beans and peas, dark-green leafy vegetables, bread, whole-grain cereals, and dairy product. Vitamin C;Citrus fruits, berries, rose hips, capsicum, strawberries, broccoli, rockmelons, tomatoes, and leafy greens. Vitamin D; Fatty fish such as herring, salmon, and tuna, dairy products, eggs, summer sun, and breakfast cereals. Vitamin E; I know that Cold pressed vegetable oils, nuts, dark-green leafy vegetables, organic meats, seafood, eggs, and avocados have it. Vitamin K; Spinach, asparagus, cabbage, brussels sprouts, cauliflower, broccoli, turnip greens, or other dark leafy vegetables, beef, liver; green tea; cheese, egg yolks, and oats. :
:
:
:
:
|
:
|
:
:
I am open minded. Very open minded, actually. And I love trying new things! Also new foods. I just don't want to eat meat any more, so I wont be trying new meat foods. Geez, what a lost... I know many sources, where you can get vitamin B from. I've done my studying. :
:
:
:
So you were kidding about wanting a barbie doll body, because you've already got one...? Or there was the sarcasm and you don't have one..? :
:
|
:
:
:
:
:
|
:
:
:
I have said: :
:
:
:
:
|
:
:
|
:
:
|
:
I know. and it does not prove that you know more than me because you don't know anyone's IQ status to say that. I never said it proved I knew more than you. I don't claim to, and I'm sure you know more than me. I was pointing out that in my twisted opinion it sounded like you were trying to prove you knew a heck of a lot about nutrition, but in doing so sounded like you knew no more than me, who knows very little about nutrition. Or something like that. It was not designed to cause offence. I'm very sorry for any caused, and take back all comments. Please forgive me. Peace out? :) |
:
|
:
:
:
************************ :
:
|
:
:
|
I am a vegetarian and I agree with every radical vegetarian idea out there. I don't drink milk, either. Milk is wack! McDonald's is wack! Ahhh! Too many carnivores! All our hunger problems would be solved if we stopped raising animals. Vegetables are infinetely more effiecient to produce. And what happens when this lust for flesh (not to criticize lust, I'm just talking about meat) goes too far? What happens when we're next? When population outstrips food production? Has anyone seen Soylent Green?
|
:
And yes I have seen that movie. It's a classic. *mutters something about thinking this topic had died...* |
Yes, this topic has died. Cause of death: the inability for meat-eaters to justify their diet.
|