Oddworld Forums

Oddworld Forums (http://www.oddworldforums.net/index.php)
-   Oddworld Discussion (http://www.oddworldforums.net/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Oddworld: SoulStorm (http://www.oddworldforums.net/showthread.php?t=22155)

Nepsotic 04-20-2016 12:42 AM

The backwards R is so dumb

Also I think it could totally be done. You could have him start out crawling, having to find pants, maybe have o find propellers for some puzzles in order to progress etc.

STM 04-20-2016 01:09 AM

I agree with Nepsotic, plus you get the chance to learn something about slig culture, or rather, what industrial slig culture has become. I'm sure I've read that sligs are naturally a nurturing species. We could find out about Skillya a little bit and you know, there's really scope to draw parallels to real life genetic ethical debates, as well as persecution, racism and ethnic/ social cleansing (see: rights of albinos in some Sub-Saharan countries).

I've always wanted to see Sligstorm come to fruition because I want to see how puzzles will revolve around a slig's limited mobility; although the flying harness alleviated some of that. Vlam you need to engage your imagination and see that it does not have to follow the boundaries of the previous games, it can build on existing canon without altering it.

Yes yes I know I said I'd be gone for a while but I'm at work and this is a pretty interesting thread.

Vlam 04-20-2016 01:59 AM

STM, you're describing a fangame. I will tell you why:

:

We could find out about Skillya a little bit and you know,
1. It doesn't make sense from a storytelling perspective. Queens were supposed to appear in MO, not before. No, they won't show Skillya in this little DLC. It's like knowing who are the investors in AE: can't happen.

:

there's really scope to draw parallels to real life genetic ethical debates, as well as persecution, racism and ethnic/ social cleansing (see: rights of albinos in some Sub-Saharan countries).
2. I understand. Except that the Albino Slig seems normal in Alf's Escape...

:

Vlam you need to engage your imagination and see that it does not have to follow the boundaries of the previous games,
I'm talking (since the beginning) about what can realistically be done by OWI. Money doesn't grow on trees.

Nepsotic 04-20-2016 02:07 AM

How could you tell he seemed normal in Alf's Escape? The poor bastard would probably love a drink after being through hell. He doesn't "seem" anything because we know nothing about him.

Vlam 04-20-2016 02:16 AM

:

()
How could you tell he seemed normal in Alf's Escape? The poor bastard would probably love a drink after being through hell. He doesn't "seem" anything because we know nothing about him.

There's 3 sligs lying on the floor.

kjjcarpenter 04-20-2016 02:23 AM

I always assumed that slig in Alf's Bar was normal, just in an awkward lighting position. Is the albino slig Wildum then?

Vlam 04-20-2016 02:25 AM

:

()
I always assumed that slig in Alf's Bar was normal, just in an awkward lighting position. Is the albino slig Wildum then?

No, isn't he supposed to be dead?

Nepsotic 04-20-2016 02:31 AM

I don't understand why you would think that?

STM 04-20-2016 02:58 AM

:

()
STM, you're describing a fangame. I will tell you why:


1. It doesn't make sense from a storytelling perspective. Queens were supposed to appear in MO, not before. No, they won't show Skillya in this little DLC. It's like knowing who are the investors in AE: can't happen.


2. I understand. Except that the Albino Slig seems normal in Alf's Escape...


I'm talking (since the beginning) about what can realistically be done by OWI. Money doesn't grow on trees.

1.) What is, and what was meant to be, are two different things. Yes, we were supposed to learn of Sam and Maggie in MO, but in reality, we received something far more watered down, with no mention of Sam. I don't recall ever hearing that Skillya was supposed to be unveiled within the MO storyline either. Just because something was meant to happen, does not mean it has to. Your looking at this inflexibly.

2.) We don't know the timing of Sligstorm, it could have happened long before or after Alf's Escape; the appearance of the albino in Alf's Escape was an Easter egg right? Why then must it belong to the canon of the game, as opposed to a wink and nudge to those in the know about the relevance of an albino slig? Besides, one single sighting of an albino in the game does not set the precedent for the entire subgroup, he had nothing to react to, so how can you know whether he's persecuted?

3.) Why can OWI not recycle existing assets and create Sligstorm as a DLC, just as they did for Alf's Escape? That does not breach the boundaries of reality.

kjjcarpenter 04-20-2016 04:15 AM

I think the crux of vlam's arguement is that unless Sligstorm is going to add something new, in terms of story—which is unlikely, especially if it follows the same trend as Alf's Escape, with little Easter Eggs scattered throughout—or some significant gameplay tweaks, there's not a huge incentive to go ahead with it.

I don't necessarily agree, however, I was somewhat underwhelmed with Alf's Escape; a challenging adventure it might have been, but I would have preferred some stronger, Quintology-related mythology, perhaps digging deeper into the RuptureFarms ethos, uncovering some larger-world information, etc. I think I'm in a minority on that though.

Vlam 04-20-2016 06:05 AM

STM,

1. Is "storytelling" the correct word? In AO, you're against Molluck. In AE, you're against more Glukkons. In MO, you learn more about the societal hierarchy of Glukkons. You see, the story is progressive. In AE, you aren't even aware of the existence of the Big Bro Sligs. You put the cart before the horse by showing Skillya now. It's too soon. They will show the Queens in MO (or ME).

2. The Slig seems "normal" (with his pants) to me. Moreover, if he was persecuted, why would he stay near 3 Sligs? By the way, Wil said that (it could be something new):
:

But consider that was one pitch 17 years ago. The premise of 'albino Slig fights persecution' has evolved a lot in that time. There's no reason to confine it to existing sets. The only thing that's been set in stone is that the poor chump is sitting there in Alf's bar.
3. Alf's Escape was "simple" to make: it's basically an extra level with no cutscenes. The Sligstorm (DLC) you want seems overly ambitious (keep in mind that we're talking about the OWI of 2016). Furthermore, the way I see it, the reason the game wasn't released (I may be wrong): playing only as a slig isn't interesting/entertaining enough.

:

I think the crux of vlam's arguement is that unless Sligstorm is going to add something new, in terms of story—which is unlikely, especially if it follows the same trend as Alf's Escape, with little Easter Eggs scattered throughout—or some significant gameplay tweaks, there's not a huge incentive to go ahead with it.
Yes, kjjcarpenter.

JayDee 04-20-2016 06:44 AM

I feel like Vlam looks at Lorne interviews and Oddworld canon the way Westboro Baptists look at the Bible. Sure you're not wrong but where's the fun or relevance in following the exact wording of something from a completely different time to the letter (Biblically speaking, and in the context of the game's industry at the time of AO/AE) . In the nineties I said I was going to be Batman and Spiderman at the same time, but if I tried that nowadays it would just be an inconvenience.

At the end of the day Lorne's going to do what Lorne's going to do, Sligstorm or no.

Vlam 04-20-2016 06:50 AM

:

()
I feel like Vlam looks at Lorne interviews and Oddworld canon the way Westboro Baptists look at the Bible. Sure you're not wrong but where's the fun or relevance in following the exact wording of something from a completely different time to the letter (Biblically speaking, and in the context of the game's industry at the time of AO/AE) . In the nineties I said I was going to be Batman and Spiderman at the same time, but if I tried that nowadays it would just be an inconvenience.

At the end of the day Lorne's going to do what Lorne's going to do, Sligstorm or no.

Do you mean the Quran?

JayDee 04-20-2016 06:53 AM

:

()
Do you mean the Quran?

Nope.

Vlam 04-20-2016 07:10 AM

You should stop trolling. Thank you.

OWI_Pete 04-20-2016 09:06 AM

:

()
...In the nineties I said I was going to be Batman and Spiderman at the same time, but if I tried that nowadays it would just be an inconvenience.

Man, '90s you was a maverick genius. Never give up on your dreams, dude.

HOMINIX 04-20-2016 09:32 AM

:

()
I think the crux of vlam's arguement is that unless Sligstorm is going to add something new, in terms of story—which is unlikely, especially if it follows the same trend as Alf's Escape, with little Easter Eggs scattered throughout—or some significant gameplay tweaks, there's not a huge incentive to go ahead with it.

I completely disagree. A story can massively benefit from putting the audience in the shoes of someone on the other side. They would have a chance to show how sligs work within their ranks, and generally add depth to the oddworld universe. I imagine the puzzles would feel noticeably different to adjust for the inability to chant or to compensate for having a gun if they choose to give you one.

I've said this before, but plenty of people would be happy to buy Sligstorm based on the idea alone and the fact that it's now one of the mythologized "lost works" of oddworld - the kind that devoted fans drool over.

The game seems like it would work well in the format of the Abe games, and I don't believe they would ever make it a standalone game, so I think it's plausible for them to develop Sligstorm for DLC

As for "skillya'" in the bar in NNT, I'm sure there are several albino sligs, and even if it is indeed Skillya, I'm sure they would have no problem disregarding that easter egg cameo with a contradictory timeline. Hell, the whole script is being rewritten, so I don't think a good idea would be put on halt because they decided to do a bit of fan service in the form of an Easter egg.

Manco 04-20-2016 10:33 AM

:

()
I think the crux of vlam's arguement is that unless Sligstorm is going to add something new, in terms of story—which is unlikely, especially if it follows the same trend as Alf's Escape, with little Easter Eggs scattered throughout—or some significant gameplay tweaks, there's not a huge incentive to go ahead with it.

OK, but then realistically there’s no way to make SligStorm without including something new – if the game was presented without any kind of framing story or explanation people would have no idea what was going on, and everything previously revealed about what SligStorm could be points to a new story. It’s standalone from everything else, so a new story is necessary for it to work at all.

Ali’s Escape didn’t focus on story because it was an add-on to New ‘n’ Tasty – it reused setting, characters and gameplay mechanics. There’s no way they could do the same with SligStorm because it’s too different to any other game.

Vlam 04-20-2016 10:46 AM

Yes, so it's possible to have a DLC (with Abe as a playable character) set during AE or between AE and MO.

kjjcarpenter 04-20-2016 11:14 AM

Just dug this up: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/commen...tewart/c7jow6y

Lorne seems hesitant about the idea.

Vlam 04-20-2016 11:15 AM

:

()
Just dug this up: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/commen...tewart/c7jow6y

Lorne seems hesitant about the idea.

Great find!

kjjcarpenter 04-20-2016 11:27 AM

No worries. ;)

:

()
OK, but then realistically there’s no way to make SligStorm without including something new – if the game was presented without any kind of framing story or explanation people would have no idea what was going on, and everything previously revealed about what SligStorm could be points to a new story. It’s standalone from everything else, so a new story is necessary for it to work at all.

Ali’s Escape didn’t focus on story because it was an add-on to New ‘n’ Tasty – it reused setting, characters and gameplay mechanics. There’s no way they could do the same with SligStorm because it’s too different to any other game.

I absolutely agree with you, though it all depends on the budget, eh?

JayDee 04-20-2016 12:01 PM

:

()
Man, '90s you was a maverick genius. Never give up on your dreams, dude.

I used to wear a spiderman costume at the same time as a batman hood and cape, it was magical.

If there's anything I'd like to see in New N Tasty it's a return of the big moving saws from Alf's Escape, maybe in the form of a tunnel borer or something.

Nate 04-20-2016 09:03 PM

:

()
Just dug this up: https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/commen...tewart/c7jow6y

Lorne seems hesitant about the idea.

See, that sounds to me like he's excited about the challenge of a difficult problem.

kjjcarpenter 04-20-2016 11:30 PM

:

()
See, that sounds to me like he's excited about the challenge of a difficult problem.

Ah, the ambiguity of the written word.

I never considered his tone to be challenging, but now that you mention it, it does seem like a very Lorne-thing to say.

Vlam 04-21-2016 01:18 AM

:

A big question is... how will people react to a Hero that is a slig. Sligs ain't so pretty, i mean they even make Abe looks handsome. So this is a curious challenge and would like to get feedback into the idea of a Slig as a hero in a game. Well, it's actually an albino slig.
In my opinion, it's a diplomatic way to say "I don't want to make this game".
I mean, he can't ignore this fact: the fans fantasize about Sligstorm.

STM 04-21-2016 01:27 AM

I'm legitimately interested, Vlam; what do you want to see happen next with Oddworld? You've pooh-pooh'd Sligstorm, NnT, the Soulstorm ARG, there really leaves very little scope for what you actually do want to happen. Do you have a sort of puritanical view of the franchise, where everything has to happen according to OWI's plan pre-2001?

Vlam 04-21-2016 01:57 AM

:

()
I'm legitimately interested, Vlam; what do you want to see happen next with Oddworld? You've pooh-pooh'd Sligstorm, NnT, the Soulstorm ARG, there really leaves very little scope for what you actually do want to happen. Do you have a sort of puritanical view of the franchise, where everything has to happen according to OWI's plan pre-2001?

Why are you so "aggressive"? You know, OWI has nothing to do with me. To answer your question: Squeek's Oddysee is the game I want to see the most.

kjjcarpenter 04-21-2016 02:15 AM

:

()
Why are you so "aggressive"? You know, OWI has nothing to do with me. To answer your question: Squeek's Oddysee is the game I want to see the most.

Vlam, do you think Munch's Oddysee will be reworked into a new game, with the deleted story threads intact, or do you think Oddworld Inc will skip ahead to Squeek? OWI_Pete seems to imply the reworked ending of Soulstorm might segue into something different than we anticipate.

Varrok 04-21-2016 02:22 AM

I hope they remade MO that will be completely different to the original, and better. Just so people will stop complaining

Vlam 04-21-2016 02:25 AM

:

()
Vlam, do you think Munch's Oddysee will be reworked into a new game, with the deleted story threads intact, or do you think Oddworld Inc will skip ahead to Squeek? OWI_Pete seems to imply the reworked ending of Soulstorm might segue into something different than we anticipate.

I do not know more than you.

kjjcarpenter 04-21-2016 02:27 AM

:

()
I do not know more than you.

Would you like if it was remade, or would you prefer them to skip to Squeek?

Lol, Varrok, I concur.

Vlam 04-21-2016 02:29 AM

Ah, sure, I would prefer them to skip to Squeek but we all know they're going to remade MO.

Nepsotic 04-21-2016 02:39 AM

:

()
I hope they remade MO that will be completely different to the original, and better. Just so people will stop complaining

I hope they remake New 'n' Tasty but completely different to the original, and better. Just so Varrok will stop complaining.

kjjcarpenter 04-21-2016 02:40 AM

I see a vicious circle forming.

Varrok 04-21-2016 02:52 AM

:

()
I hope they remake New 'n' Tasty but completely different to the original, and better. Just so Varrok will stop complaining.

But NnT *is* different to the original

Holy Sock 04-21-2016 09:28 AM

I honestly would rather a remake of MO or a ME type of game before we get to Squeek. Develop the concepts of Munch/Abe and the Sam/Maggie story before moving forward. If Squeek is supposed to be about Maggie's grandmother then we need to be exposed to Maggie first.

STM 04-21-2016 10:27 AM

I used to think we should just forget and move on from MO but these days I'm inclined to agree with the Papal Foot Garment.

Nepsotic 04-21-2016 05:24 PM

Considering there hasn't been an Oddworld game better than the first one - 18 years ago - how much hope do we have for Soulstorm and the future of the series?

Crashpunk 04-22-2016 12:18 AM

I've got high hopes for Soulstorm because they can know from experience with NnT what worked and what didn't. I don't think it's going to be a whole to different in terms of gameplay, but I do think it's going to be a lot more refined. Also the route they seem to be taking Soulstorm is very appealing to me and many other Oddworld fans.

As for the future. I hope they don't do anymore remakes. It's finally time to make something new. People will want a MO remake. And as much as that game needs a rewrite and a redesign. Again. it's time for something new. Oddworld has already gained enough attention to start making new shit now.

I think the next new game will be Munch's Exoddus. We know Munch so it'll be safer for OWI to have a new game with characters we already know. Other then that, I think we could get a game like Stranger's Wraith down the line. Perhaps The Brutal Ballad of Fangus.